Ca
of
Wh
Increase
automat
lcula
a Mi
ite Paper
your operat
ed, goods‐to
ting t
spick
ion’s accura
‐person, sto
he T
cy and redu
rage and re
rue C
ce costs ass
trieval syste
ost
ociated with
ms
errors by deploying
Introd
Most orde
customer
Picking in
distributio
and wher
refers to t
items, con
All of thos
through a
most facil
These pic
Th
Th
A
Th
So, while
the true c
calculatio
technolog
can delive
Doing
In Octobe
United Kin
“distribut
The cost o
with shipp
1 Tobias Ra
2014, http
06%20Acti
2 “Mis‐Pick
www.inter
uction: W
r fulfillment
order have e
volves much
n center, pic
e, travels to t
he paper pic
firms the pic
e steps are f
warehouse a
ities, and it’s
king mistakes
e wrong item
e wrong qua
n item is omi
e condition
most operati
ost of those m
n for estimat
y solutions to
r.
the Math
r 2012, a surv
gdom, Franc
ion centers a
f a picking m
ing the item
mmelmeier, e
://www.fml.m
ve%20prevent
s Cost Busines
mec.com/abo
hat is a
operations u
xperienced p
more than gr
king means a
he correct st
k list to deter
k by marking
raught with p
gain and aga
easy to see w
, or mispicks
is picked in
ntity of item
tted, or not p
of the item it
ons understa
ispicks, and
ing the true c
improve pic
: How M
ey of 250 su
e and Germa
re losing an a
istake includ
back, proces
t al. “Active Pr
w.tum.de/fml/
ion%20of%20
ses Nearly $39
ut_us/newsro
Mispick?
tilizing opera
icking errors
abbing an ite
n operator r
orage locatio
mine the num
the paper, t
otential for e
in throughou
hy picking m
, come in a va
stead of (or i
s is picked, e
icked at all.
self is unacce
nd mistakes
how they im
ost of mispic
k accuracy, a
uch Doe
pply chain an
ny—conduct
verage of ne
es not only th
sing it upon r
evention of Pi
images/Publik
picking%20err
0,000 Per Yea
om/press_rele
tors to manu
. That’s beca
m off a static
eceives a pap
n, locates the
ber of item
hen delivers t
rror. Factor
t a shift, and
istakes happ
riety of type
n addition to
ither too man
ptable, such
will happen,
pact the bot
ks in order fu
nd shares a c
s a Mispi
d distributio
ed by resear
arly $390,000
e cost of the
eceipt, retur
cking Errors by
ationen/2011
ors%20by%20
r According to
ases/2013‐01‐
ally select re
use humans a
storage rack
er list of inst
correct item
s required fro
he items for
in increasing
the typically
en.
s. Among the
) the correct
y or two few
as damaged
very few hav
tom line. This
lfillment to a
alculation fo
ck Cost?
n managers a
ch company
per year du
item, but al
ning it to sto
Employing Pi
‐
employing%20
Intermec Stu
21‐Mis‐Picks‐
quired produ
re prone to
or shelf. In t
ructions abo
within that
m that pick f
packing.
fatigue as an
less‐than‐op
m:
one.
.
or mis‐labele
e taken the t
white paper
n operation.
r determinin
cross the Un
Vanson Bour
e to mispicks
so “the expen
ck, and loss o
ck‐by‐Vision,”
Pick‐by‐Vision
dy,” accessed
Cost‐Businesse
2 | P
cts to fill a
making mista
he typical m
ut what to pi
storage locat
ace, picks th
operator wa
timal lighting
d.1
ime to calcula
outlines a
It also prese
g the savings
ited States,
ne—found
.”2
ses associat
f customer
accessed, Ma
.pdf
January 4, 201
s.aspx
a g e
kes.
anual
ck
ion,
e
lks
in
te
nts
they
ed
y 15,
4,
satisfactio
item back
An estima
a slim ma
A
pe
Th
eq
TABLE
Lines p
Averag
SKUs P
One 8
SKUs P
Mispic
Mispic
Averag
Total L
Workin
Total L
Reduci
Automate
carousels
search tim
storage an
error by h
1
2
3
4
3 Hannah K
http://www
4 Ibid.
n.”3 Further
to the custo
ted 35% of fa
rgin for impro
facility pickin
r day picks 6
e cost of eac
ual $6,000 in
1: Calculatin
er Hour
e SKUs/Orde
icked per Ho
Hour Shift
icked per Day
k Rate
ks per Day
e Cost of a M
ost Revenue
g Days per Y
ost Revenue
ng Mispi
d, goods‐to‐
and vertical
e, as well as
d retrieval s
elping opera
. Picking a s
. Putting an
. Communic
. Completin
ain, “Simple F
.alom.com/r
time is lost in
mer.
cilities exper
vement, it a
g 250 lines p
,000 items d
h mispick… c
lost revenue
g the Cost of
r
ur
ispick
per Day
ear
per Year
cks: Ligh
person storag
lift modules (
fatigue. In ad
ystems can b
tors with fou
pecific or act
item in an ac
ating a mess
g the pick an
ulfillment Erro
esources/focu
correcting t
ience ongoin
dds up quick
er hour, aver
aily. If 1% of t
an average a
a day.4
a 1% Mispick
Example
65
x 3
= 195
x 8
= 1,560
x 1%
= 15.6
x $100
= $1,560
x 260
= $405,60
t‐Directe
e and retriev
VLMs)—deliv
dition to del
e equipped w
r basic functi
ive item
tive order or
age such as a
d moving on
rs Will Affect T
s.asp?file=002
he mistake by
g mispick rat
ly, as illustrat
aging three S
hose picks ar
s much as $1
Rate
1 E
0 = $
d Solutio
al systems—
er items dire
ivering the it
ith light‐dire
ons:
location
quantity or
to the next p
he Bottom Lin
.inc.
picking, pac
es of 1% or m
ed here (and
KUs per orde
e incorrect, t
00 apiece, or
xample 2
250
x 3
= 750
x 8
= 6,000
x 1%
= 60
x $100
= $6,000
x 260
1,560,000
ns Boost
such as horiz
ctly to an op
ems directly
cted picking
description o
ick
e,” accessed J
king and ship
ore. Althoug
in Table 1):
r, and runnin
hat translate
more. There
Calcula
Picking
ontal carous
erator, elimin
to the operat
features whi
f the item
anuary 5, 201
3 | P
ping the cor
h 1% sounds
g one 8‐hou
s to 60 mispi
fore, 60 misp
te Your Own
Accuracy
els, vertical
ating walk a
or, automate
ch negate hu
4,
a g e
rect
like
r shift
cks.
icks
nd
d
man
Light‐dire
the opera
descriptio
quantity.
customer
To increas
automate
Transactio
carousels
displays d
incremen
quantities
select the
fulfillmen
Light Poin
LED or las
horizonta
opening o
driven, th
light beam
illuminate
light spot
be picked
Position I
access op
vertical ca
alignment
where it i
cted picking t
tor the precis
n, pinpoint t
Not only do t
s who are mo
e picking acc
d storage an
n Informatio
and VLMs, th
iscrete item
ts. The modu
and other m
correct item
t.
ter: Used wit
er light moun
lly on a guidi
f the storage
e light pointe
in the dept
any position
identifies the
or replenishe
ndicator Ligh
enings of bot
rousels, thes
with the pos
s stored in th
echnologies
e area withi
he exact loca
hese devices
re likely to b
uracy up to 9
d retrieval sy
n Center: Ap
is dynamic p
identification
le displays de
essages to h
and amount
h VLMs, this
ted on a slid
ng system wi
and retrieva
r also swivel
h direction of
within the s
precise loca
d, eliminatin
t Bar: Incorp
h vertical lift
e LED lights i
ition of the r
e tray.
have evolved
n the carrier
tion, direct e
dramatically
uy again.
9.9%, the fo
stems:
plied to vert
ick‐to‐light sy
in 1/10‐inch
scriptions,
elp an operat
for order
system deplo
er that move
thin the acce
l unit. Softwa
s to project t
the machine
torage tray. T
tion of the it
g search tim
orated into t
modules and
lluminate in
equired item
into comple
of the item to
ither picking
reduce picki
llowing light‐
ical
stem
or
ys an
s
ss
re‐
he
to
he
em to
e.
he
te message c
be picked, d
or storage, a
ng mistakes,
directed tech
enters that c
isplay the pa
nd indicate th
but they also
nologies can
4 | P
ommunicate
rt number o
e required
lead to happ
be added to
a g e
to
r
ier
Light Tow
carousels,
extruded
active car
to pick. So
two horiz
pod.
Put/Batch
vertical ca
directed p
store item
replenishi
consolida
workstati
retrieval u
TABLE 2: L
Transactio
Informatio
Light Poin
Position In
Light Bar
Light Towe
Put/Batch
In additio
incorpora
picking m
correct nu
er: When int
this unit hou
uprights (tow
ousel, shelf le
ftware‐drive
ontal carouse
Lights: Used
rousels, as w
icking modu
s in a specifi
ng stock. The
tion, batch pi
ons located n
nits.
ight‐Directed
n
n Center
ter
dicator
r
Lights
n to these lig
te radio‐freq
odules that g
mber of sma
egrated with
ses picking d
ers). The dis
vel, cell loca
n, a single lig
ls working to
with both h
ell as VLMs,
les direct an
c or active lo
y can also be
cking and so
ear the auto
Picking Sys
Picking
x
x
x
x
ht‐directed te
uency (RF) sc
ive verbal co
ll parts have
horizontal
isplay modu
plays indicate
tion and qua
ht tower serv
gether in a p
orizontal and
these light‐
operator to p
cation when
used for ord
rtation at
mated storag
tem Add‐Ons
Capabilit
Putting
x
x
x
x
x
chnologies,
anners for ba
mmands to o
been picked
les in
the
ntity
es
icking
ut or
er
e and
That Drama
ies
Messag
x
x
automated st
rcode verific
perators wea
based on the
tically Reduc
e Horizo
x
x
orage and re
ation of pick
ring a head‐
ir weight.
e Mispicks
Integrate
ntal Vert
x
x
x
trieval syste
ed items, voi
set, or scales
5 | P
s With
ical VL
ms can also
ce‐directed
that verify th
a g e
M
x
x
x
x
e
Doing
Increasing
picking m
customer
Just how
directed p
reducing
rate even
TABLE
From T
Lost Re
with 1%
Now, le
Lines p
Averag
SKUs P
One 8
SKUs P
Mispic
Mispic
Averag
Total L
Workin
Total L
with 0.
Saving
1% and
Want E
To achiev
automate
addition t
facility’s w
function a
counts—f
the Math
pick accurac
istakes, but it
satisfaction w
much cost sa
icking techno
pick error fro
slightly yield
3: Calculate
able 1 Above
venue per Ye
Mispick Rat
t’s calculate
er Hour
e SKUs/Orde
icked per Ho
Hour Shift
icked per Day
k Rate
ks per Day
e Cost of a M
ost Revenue
g Days per Y
ost Revenue p
1% Mispick R
s per Year Be
0.1% Mispic
ven Gre
e the highest
d storage an
o keeping tra
arehouse m
llows manag
or better inv
: Calcula
y, even by le
will also res
ill improve,
vings can res
logies? Tabl
m 1% (calcula
s a 90% cost
the Savings f
:
ar
e
the cost of 0
r
ur
ispick
per Day
ear
er Year
ate
tween
k Rate
ater Accu
degree of pi
d retrieval sy
ck of the con
anagement s
ers to closely
entory contro
te the Sa
ss than a per
ult in tremen
likely leading
ult from using
e 3 shares tw
ted in Table
savings.
rom Fewer M
Example
$405,600
.1% Mispick
65
x 3
= 195
x 8
= 1,560
x 0.1%
= 1.56
x $100
= $156
x 260
= $40,56
$365,040
90% Cost Sav
racy? In
cking accurac
stem enables
tents stored
ystem (WMS
monitor sto
l.
vings fro
cent, will not
dous cost sav
to an increa
automated
o examples o
1) to 0.1%. A
ispicks
1 E
$
Rate
0 =
ings
$
90%
tegrate In
y, integrating
smart functi
within the m
) and enterpr
ck levels in re
m Fewe
only contrib
ings, as show
se in repeat
storage syste
f the cost sa
s the table sh
xample 2
1,560,000
250
x 3
= 750
x 8
= 6,000
x 0.1%
= 6
x $100
= $600
x 260
$156,000
1,404,000
Cost Savings
ventory
inventory m
onality such
achine, the s
ise resource
al time—and
r Mispick
ute to a dram
n in Table 3
purchases.
ms that inco
vings that ca
ows, reducin
Calcula
Control
anagement
as inventory
oftware also
planning (ER
potentially
6 | P
s
atic reductio
. Further,
rporate light
n be gained b
g the mispic
te Your Own
x 0.1%
Software
software with
monitoring. I
interfaces w
P) systems. T
eliminate phy
a g e
n in
‐
y
k
an
n
ith a
his
sical
For examp
each picke
verifies th
also be us
item and
storage an
significant
Likewise,
control, th
paramete
selectively
For facilit
serial num
applicatio
correct ite
Finally, in
software
maintains
fulfilled. S
locations
Examp
Jazz Avi
The 6,900
around‐th
watch ove
le, in system
d item. The
at the picked
ed when rep
its destinatio
d retrieval s
ly reducing m
for operation
e software c
rs. Qualifiers
boosting ac
ies requiring
ber—visual
ns, barcode s
m has been
highly regula
functionality
a record of t
hould a defe
of both stock
les of Inc
ation
‐square‐foot
e‐clock repa
r the 20,000
s equipped w
data capture
part is the s
lenishing inve
n to verify pla
ystem ensure
ispicks.
s that stock a
an be configu
can be limite
curacy and co
an operator t
verification c
canning can
picked, savin
ted industrie
can be levera
he item, the
ct be identifie
ed and shipp
reased A
maintenance
irs to the airli
SKUs in inve
ith an RF ba
d by the scan
ame one req
ntory in the
cement into
s additional
few high do
red to requi
d to certain t
ntrol withou
o match part
an be tedious
be used to ve
g time, ensur
s such as me
ged for its tr
date it was p
d, or a recal
ed products.
ccuracy
stockroom f
ne’s fleet of
ntory.
rcode scanne
ner is relayed
uired by the o
system. Duri
the correct s
accuracy in o
llar value ite
re a barcode
ransactions,
t sacrificing p
numbers or
, time consu
rify with the
ing accuracy
dical device,
ack‐and‐trac
icked, the op
l required, th
from Aut
or Jazz Aviat
125 planes. T
r, the operat
to the inven
rder. This ba
ng restocking
torage locat
rder picking
ms, or regula
scan only wh
product type
ick speed.
pick items fr
ming and err
inventory m
.
healthcare a
e capabilities
erator who p
e software ca
omated
ion, in Toron
hat means th
or can be req
tory control
rcode recog
, the operato
ion. Adding s
and SKU repl
ted products
en triggered
s or item sto
om a specific
or‐prone. Fo
anagement s
nd pharmace
. That’s beca
icked it and
n quickly de
Storage S
to, Ontario, i
e facility has
7 | P
uired to sca
software, wh
nition feature
r scans both
canning to a
enishment,
requiring tig
by certain
rage location
batch, lot or
r these
oftware the
uticals, the s
use the softw
the order it
termine the
ystems:
s responsible
to keep clos
a g e
n
ich
can
the
hter
s,
ame
are
for
e
Further, s
peak perf
total SKUs
transactio
Every SKU
througho
was used
number. T
To verify t
tote, ensu
to the bat
Value D
To reduce
(Canada)
technolog
into order
Holding m
items with
pharmacy
working a
Because a
check out
tote it is s
accuracy.
afety is the to
ormance. To
into two VL
ns are logged
received int
ut the distrib
in each airpla
his allows Ja
he pick base
ring they hav
ch picking an
rug Mart
labor requir
replaced two
y. Stacked an
s, with a bat
ore than 10,
an average
items with a
5‐hour shift,
ccuracy is ex
scanner) is m
canned for a
p priority at
secure parts
Ms. The VLM
and traceab
o inventory h
ution channe
ne. Upon pic
zz to trace w
d on the batc
e picked not
d validation
ements and s
zones of stat
d organized
ching station
000 total SKU
pick rate of 3
n average pic
reducing the
tremely impo
ounted at e
ccuracy verifi
Jazz. The pro
and keep bet
s’ integrated
le, keeping a
as a batch, o
l, because it
king, the ope
hat batch nu
h number, th
only the righ
process, accu
peed picking
ic shelving w
into two zon
that accomm
s, the lower
50 lines per
k rate of 575
total man h
rtant to the
ach end of th
cation. The s
tection of inv
ter track of t
inventory ma
irplanes and
r lot, numbe
is crucial to k
rator must p
mber is put in
e operator s
t part numbe
racy has incr
productivity
ith six horizo
es of three ca
odates simu
carousel zon
hour, while t
lines per ho
ours for picki
company, a f
e batch statio
can helps Va
entory is cru
hem, the com
nagement so
passengers s
r. The batch n
now what pa
ick a specific
to each orde
cans the part
r, but also th
eased to mo
, Value Drug
ntal carouse
rousels each
ltaneous fulf
e manages 3,
he upper caro
ur. Each zone
ng from 36 to
ixed‐position
n. Before ea
lue Drug Mar
cial to keepi
pany conso
ftware ensu
afe.
umber must
rt number an
part and a sp
r and used o
before it goe
e correct ba
re than 99%.
Mart in Edm
ls integrated
, picked item
illment of up
100 general
usel zone m
is picked by
10 hours a
scanner (sim
ch item is pla
t maintain ne
8 | P
ng airplanes
lidated half o
res that all
be traceable
d batch num
ecific batch
n each plane
s into the or
tch number.
onton, Albert
with pick‐to‐
s are batche
to 10 orders
merchandise
anages 7,100
a single ope
day.
ilar to a reta
ced in the o
ar perfect pi
a g e
at
f its
ber
.
der
Due
a
light
d
.
rator
il
rder
ck
Christie
At project
(Canada),
manufact
improve p
cart‐based
In additio
the comp
adherenc
inventory
Previously
required s
automatic
are retriev
To learn m
profits by
About K
Kardex Re
retrieval s
about the
ion technolo
the company
uring process
roduction ca
storage sys
n to recoveri
any was able
e to a first‐in/
, it is stored b
, it took one
ub‐assembly
ally locates a
ed 90% faste
ore about h
nearly elimin
ardex Rem
mstar, LLC, a
ystems for m
company’s d
gy manufactu
custom buil
is based on
pacity by dou
tem to two V
ng 70% of flo
to leverage t
first‐out (FIF
y both serial
of four work
unit by visua
nd delivers t
r with half th
ow automate
ating mispic
star
company of
anufacturing
ynamic stora
rer Christie’
ds systems fo
Kaizen Lean M
bling its inve
LMs.
or space, dou
he VLMs’ inv
O) picking st
number and
ers dedicated
lly checking
he correct su
e number of
d storage sys
ks, contact yo
the Kardex G
, distribution
ge solutions,
s worldwide m
r cinemas, e
anufacturin
ntory of sub
bling capacit
entory mana
rategy. When
date.
to the proce
each item’s s
b‐assembly i
employees.
# # #
tems can im
ur Kardex Re
roup, is a lea
, warehousin
call 800‐639
anufacturin
ducation, me
g tenets. So
‐assembled p
y and cutting
gement softw
a projector
ss as long as
erial number
n less than a
prove your a
mstar repres
ding provide
g, offices an
‐5805 or visit
g center, in K
dia, governm
when the com
rojectors, it
labor requir
are to ensu
is received in
20 minutes t
. Now, the V
minute. As a
ccuracy and i
entative tod
r of automat
d institutions
www.Kard
9 | P
itchener, On
ent and mor
pany wante
switched from
ements in ha
re strict
to the VLMs’
o locate the
LMs’ softwar
result, proje
ncrease your
ay.
ed storage an
. For informa
exRemstar.c
a g e
tario
e. Its
d to
a
lf,
e
ctors
d
tion
om.
Calculating the True Cost of a Mispick
This white paper outlines a calculation for estimating the true cost of mispicks in order fulfillment to an operation. It also presents technology solutions to improve pick accuracy, and shares a calculation for determining the savings they can deliver.