What Carbon Footprint?

Corus replaced multiple air pollution control systems with one Spooner Anguil regenerative thermal oxidizer, and in doing so, eliminated nearly 8,000 tons of carbon per year.

Anguil CorusIn case you haven’t heard, our planet is getting warmer. At what rate it is occurring or how much human activity has to do with the increasing temperatures is a heated debate, pardon the pun. One thing we do know for sure is that carbon dioxide (CO2) is a contributing factor in global warming, and humans are responsible for a large portion of these emissions.

If you had asked someone five years ago what his or her carbon footprint was, most people would have likely responded by looking towards their feet, thinking they stepped in something. That same person would probably laugh uncontrollably if you had told them that Al Gore, former vice president of the United States and once presidential hopeful, would star in a 2006 movie that brought climate change to the forefront by drawing millions of viewers from all over the world.     

Indeed, things are much different today than they were five years ago; individuals and businesses alike are trying to reduce their environmental impact and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions. What the average person does not realize is that they have two types of footprints, a primary and secondary. The primary footprint is a measure of our direct emissions of CO2 from the burning of fossil fuels, including domestic energy consumption and transportation, e.g. car and plane. The secondary footprint is a measure of indirect CO2 emissions from the whole lifecycle of products we use, those associated with their manufacturing and eventual breakdown. To put it simply — the more we buy, the more emissions are caused on our behalf.  

Thankfully, companies like Corus, a subsidiary of Tata Steel, are doing their part to reduce the world’s secondary footprint by improving the energy efficiency of their manufacturing processes. Corus is Europe’s second largest steel producer and comprises three operating divisions: Strip Products, Long Products and Distribution & Building Systems. Corus Colors, part of the Strip Products Division, is an international business manufacturing pre-finished steel for the building envelope, domestic appliance and manufactured goods markets.

Corus Colors - Shotton Works, located in Deeside, North Wales, produces organic paint-coated prefinished steel principally for cladding, composite walling and roofing applications within the building and construction sector both in the UK and overseas.

There are two manufacturing processes at Shotton Works for coating steel strip with paint. They use a series of driven roller coaters and industrial curing ovens, controlled within a continuous process line, that are capable of applying protective and decorative high-quality finishes to the galvanized flat steel strip substrate. The No. 1 Colorcoat line process is capable of coating strip widths up to 1,400 mm with a thickness up to 1.6 mm, giving a weekly throughput capability of up to 4,000 tons, subject to product type and dimensions.

This manufacturing process requires large amounts of natural gas to ensure proper application and fast curing time in the ovens, which in turn, generate a substantial amount of CO2 and nitrous oxides (NOX). In addition to these emissions, the solvent-based coatings release hazardous air pollutants (HAPs) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs) during the drying process that need to be treated by an air pollution control device, such as an oxidizer.

New oxidizer systems are capable of destroying more than 99 percent of the HAPs and VOCs through the process of high-temperature destruction with very little fuel consumption. However, older technologies can be a source of CO2 and NOX, as well as the requirement for high maintenance and large operating expenditures.       

Pollution control initiatives are nothing new to Corus. The company has been monitoring and controlling their oven emissions at the Shotton Works facility since the 1970s. Its first oxidizer/incinerator was installed on the paint-coating processes for abating exhaust gases and solvents. Even then, the company was thinking green by utilizing waste heat from these older oxidizers/incinerators to pre-heat the ovens and supply their manufacturing facility with additional process steam.

However, as environmental regulations tightened, energy prices increased and new technologies emerged, the company decided to re-evaluate their entire system as part of their manufacturing efficiency improvements, as well as the wider corporate responsibility program for energy usage reduction. The objective was to reduce gas consumption by at least 45 percent and increase processing speeds on certain products, but the company quickly realized another benefit to their sustainable energy plans … a much smaller carbon footprint.   

Looking for a sustainable energy solution, the company turned to Spooner Industries in the United Kingdom, which has worked closely with Corus on a number of projects over the past 30 years. Oven technology and safety regulations had changed dramatically since the line was first installed, but Spooner was able to successfully complete several upgrades that brought the system up to current standards, plus increase flexibility:

  • Each zone was retrofitted with a special low NOX burner to reduce emissions.
  • Variable-frequency drives or inverters on every oven fan were incorporated into the control system to make each section more efficient and reduce electrical consumption.
  • The ductwork was changed to bring hot air into the system quickly, reducing maintenance issues.
  • New thermocouples (temperature measurement), pressure transmitters, pressure switches and flow measurement systems were installed in the ovens to bring the equipment up to today’s technology standards, allowing for remote monitoring and fine-tuning.
  • A new computer-controlled system was integrated with the system control and data acquisition (SCADA) program. The proper programmable logic controller (PLC) allows the central Corus system to communicate with the ovens so they can be set up for different production runs, eliminating errors and decreasing setup time.

These oven alterations brought this production line from the least efficient in the Corus group to the most, meeting one of the two objectives for the company. While some of these improvements reduced the company’s environmental footprint and gas consumption, the increased throughput would further complicate their environmental responsibilities.  

Two existing inefficient oxidizers for the prime and finish ovens were being used to control VOC and HAP emissions at the North Wales facility. To achieve proper destruction, the systems required large amounts of natural gas, which affected operating expenses and contributed to CO2 and NOX emissions. Furthermore, breakdowns and maintenance problems were not only costing the company money to repair, but also revenue in lost production.

Because the oven and oxidizer are so vital to each other, Corus wanted a solution provider with experience and knowledge on both. In addition, they were looking for a system with low operating costs and heat recovery capabilities that could achieve 99.5 percent destruction removal efficiency (DRE), which was well above their permit requirements.  

Spooner, having recently partnered with Anguil Environmental Systems in the United States to fabricate and install their oxidizer designs on applications throughout Europe, was confident that it could be done. After consulting with the engineers at both Spooner Industries and Anguil Environmental Systems, Corus made the decision to replace its multiple air pollution control systems with one regenerative thermal oxidizer (RTO) from Spooner Anguil. It would give them the desired efficiency and single-source solution for which the company was looking.

The system has the following features and benefits:

  • The oxidizer is a three-chamber design that processes 83,000 NM3/hour (55,000 SCFM) of air, achieving 99 percent or more DRE without visible emissions and 85 percent or more heat recovery for energy-efficient operation.
  • The RTO self-sustains at low solvent-loading conditions, meaning that once the oxidizer is at operating temperature and receiving process air flow, it requires no additional fuel for emission destruction, releasing very little CO2 and NOX.
  • A secondary heat exchanger sends waste heat directly back to the ovens, reducing the amount of natural gas required for product curing.
  • Stainless steel components throughout the system prevent corrosion and allow for high-temperature process streams.
  • A hot-gas bypass on the RTO is used during high-loading situations to avoid over-heating the oxidizer.
  • An intelligent bake-out feature cleans the RTO of condensable organics without internal fires or safety concerns.
  • The control panel has a large operator screen with a built-in maintenance manual and troubleshooting guide, thereby easing use.

Corus has made a significant investment for the new equipment, upgrades and implementation of this energy reduction project. It has dropped its cost, per ton of steel produced, considerably, and it estimates the payback will be less than one year.

The reduction in carbon emissions and energy consumption from this facility is dramatic. Its gas usage has dropped by more than 60 percent, an average reduction of 522 m³/hour (or 5,742 kW/hour) — saving more than £1million a year. At 181 grams of CO2 produced per KWH used, Corus is preventing 1 ton of carbon from reaching our atmosphere each hour, nearly 8,000 tons per year.

With innovation and continuous improvement at the heart of its business, the company is already planning for similar modifications at other Corus plants. A spokesperson from Corus comments: “We are committed to minimizing the environmental impact of our operations and our products through the adoption of sustainable practices and continuous improvement in environmental performance.”

For more information, please visit www.anguil.com or www.spooner.co.uk.