California Man Facing Prison For Economic Espionage
OAKLAND, Calif. (AP) -- A Northern California chemical engineer is facing more than 20 years in prison for a rare economic-espionage conviction for selling to China the technology that creates a white pigment.
A jury convicted Walter Liew, 56, of selling DuPont Co.'s secret recipe for making cars, paper and a long list of everyday items whiter to the Chinese government for $28 million.
Prosecutors are demanding a prison sentence of up to 22 years, arguing Liew's punishment needs to serve as a deterrent to others contemplating stealing trade secrets. Sentencing is set for Thursday.
"Defendant's conduct in this case represents a concrete threat to our nation's economic interests," prosecutor John Hemann wrote in court papers arguing for the lengthy prison sentence. Hemann argued that DuPont spent hundreds of millions of dollars and many years developing an efficient processing method for manufacturing the white pigment that enabled it to capture 20 percent of the $17 billion global market.
Liew's lawyer Stuart Gasner declined comment. In court papers, Gasner is seeking a sentence of about five years, arguing that DuPont suffered no financial harm and that much of the technology Liew sold to the Chinese was publicly available data.
Gasner portrayed Liew as a harried executive who relied on former DuPont engineers he hired to tell him if any of the technology being transferred to China belonged exclusively to DuPont. Liew's attorney says the former DuPont engineers never raised any objections.
"The evidence at trial showed Mr. Liew to be an overworked engineer trying to put together a massive project under difficult conditions and financial pressures," Gasner writes.
The U.S Probation Department is recommending a 14-year sentence. U.S. District Court Judge Jeffrey White in Oakland will decide on Thursday.
Liew and his wife, Christina Liew, launched a small California company in the 1990s aimed at exploiting China's desire to build a DuPont-like factory to manufacture the white pigment known as titanium dioxide. The Liews hired retired DuPont engineers and, according to the FBI, paid them thousands of dollars for sensitive company documents laying out a process to make the pigment.
"After many years of follow-up research and application, my company has possession and mastery of the complete DuPont way," said a 2004 letter Liew wrote to a Chinese company run by the government that was shown to the jury.
In 2009, the Chinese government-controlled Pangang Group Co. Ltd. awarded the Liews' company a $17 million contract to build a factory that could produce 100,000 metric tons of the pigment a year. The same company had earlier awarded the Liews' company millions more in similar contracts for smaller projects.
Prosecutors allege that the operating Chinese factory was built with a detailed DuPont instruction manual stamped "confidential," which earlier was used to build DuPont's newest plant in Taiwan.
Christina Liew has pleaded not guilty to economic espionage charges and awaits trial.
Robert Maegerle, a retired DuPont engineer, was convicted of economic-espionage charges along with Walter Liew in March. They are first people to be convicted of economic espionage by a jury since Congress passed the Economic Espionage Act in 1996, according to the U.S. Department of Justice. A handful of others have pleaded guilty to economic espionage charges before trial.
Federal officials say foreign governments' theft of U.S. technology is one of the biggest threats to the country's economy and national security.
"The battle against economic espionage has become one of the FBI's main fronts in its efforts to protect U.S. national security in the 21st century," said David Johnson, the FBI's special agent in charge of the San Francisco office.
Maegerle, 78, is to be sentenced later and remains free on bail.
A third man, retired DuPont engineer Timothy Spitler, committed suicide in early 2012 on the day he was to sign a plea bargain admitting his role in the conspiracy.