MnetTV          Digital Library

Search Manufacturing.net Search Manufacturing.net
Today in Manufacturing.Net

Resources
Association Links
Bookstore
Digital Library
Events Calendar
Job Search
What’s New
White Papers

Browse White Papers


News
Featured Articles
Financial News
Global Manufacturing
Government News
Mergers & Acquisitions
News Archive
People in the News

Job Search


Market Sectors
Aerospace
Automotive/Transportation
Chemical/Petroleum
Food/Beverage
Medical
Metals
Pharmaceuticals/Biotech
Plastics/Rubber
Other Manufacturing

Industry Focus
Design & Development
Electrical & Electronics
Energy
Environmental
Facilities & Operations
Labor Relations
Manufacturing Technology
Materials
Quality
Safety
Supply Chain

Amazon

About Us
Editorial Contacts
Advertise with Us

Our Partner Sites
Chem.Info
ECN
Food Manufacturing
IMPO (Industrial Maintenance & Plant Operation)
Medical Design Technology
Pharmaceutical Processing
Product Design & Development
R & D Magazine
Wireless Design & Development
Wireless Week



 


Mnet house ad 120x240



Online Startup Wants Say In Patent Disputes
By Joelle Tessler, AP Technology Writer
Manufacturing.Net - November 17, 2008

Printer Friendly     E-mail to a Colleague


WASHINGTON (AP) -- A new startup company wants to have a say in the high-stakes patent disputes that loom over many industries.

In the drug business, for instance, Pfizer Inc. is suing generics maker Teva Pharmaceutical Industries, accusing it of infringing on a patent covering Pfizer's top-selling cholesterol medicine.

In high-tech, Research In Motion Ltd. is locked in litigation with Motorola Inc. over patents central to wireless devices. And in the video game market, Konami Digital Entertainment, developer of "Rock Revolution," is pushing a patent infringement case against Harmonix Music Systems, creator of the game "Rock Band," and its corporate parents, MTV Networks and Viacom Inc.

Now the startup, Article One Partners, is offering a reward to anyone who can turn up evidence to settle whether the patents at the heart of these cases -- along with a handful of other valuable, high-profile patents -- are valid or not.

Article One Partners, which launches Monday, hopes to use the Internet to create a global community of experts to review patents issued by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. The idea is to tap the wisdom of the online masses to unearth "prior art" -- evidence that an invention is not novel and therefore doesn't deserve a patent -- that the Patent Office may not have known about when it approved the application.

To encourage people to take part, the company is offering both a profit-sharing program as well as payments of up to $50,000 to anyone who uncovers evidence that could be used to invalidate a patent. Article One Partners hopes to make money by selling the information it gathers to interested parties -- often those involved in infringement suits -- and by making market trades based on the information.

Company founder Cheryl Milone said Article One Partners plans to focus on "patents that have the greatest economic impact," particularly those that cover valuable products, are involved in costly infringement lawsuits or are in the hands of holding companies that reap royalty payments from others.

While the company's work could help invalidate some high-profile patents, it could help strengthen the legitimacy of others, noted Milone, an attorney who practiced patent law for 12 years.

Article One Partners is one of several efforts to improve patent quality and help fix an overburdened patent system that is often accused of granting too many patents of dubious merit that wind up in court.

The company hopes to build on the progress being made by Peer-to-Patent, a program run by New York Law School that publishes patent applications online in order to gather prior art to be passed along to the Patent Office during the examination process.

But there is one key difference. Unlike Peer-to-Patent, Article One Partners offers people a financial incentive to donate their time and expertise. "We feel people should be compensated for the value of their information," Milone said.


Printer Friendly     E-mail to a Colleague



Talkback!
Manufacturing.net is pleased to provide you an opportunity to share your opinions on any of the news stories or articles on our site. We reserve the right to edit/remove comments.
Viewing 1 User Comments
Add a Comment
Will it Improve the current patent situation?  11/18/2008 11:21:00 PM
If Article One Partners is able to take some of the pressure off of the current patent system--then I see it as a very positive development. Right now, too many "weak" patents are approved and that leads to court cases--let's hope this improves the situation.


Add a Comment...

E-Mail:
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Subject:
Comment:

 

     



   





Flatbed trucking, flatbed shipping, flatbed carriers



Automotive/Transportation

Volkswagen Closing In On Porsche Merger

GM To Reveal Plan For European Units In December

VW To Buy Karmann Assets


Medical

Medtronic Gets Warning On Heart Implant Unit

Stryker Acquires OtisMed, Set To Buy Other Assets

Life Technologies To Buy BioTrove

Other Manufacturing

Procter & Gamble Still Looking For Acquisitions

New Era Cap Co. Consolidating Plants

Champion: No Layoffs At Nebraska Plant
News Video