MnetTV          Digital Library

Search Manufacturing.net Search Manufacturing.net


Resources
Association Links
Bookstore
Career Center
Digital Library
Events Calendar
What’s New
White Papers


News
Featured Articles
Financial News
Global Manufacturing
Government News
Mergers & Acquisitions
News Archive
People in the News

MNet Career Center

Market Sectors
Aerospace
Automotive/Transportation
Chemical/Petroleum
Food/Beverage
Medical
Metals
Pharmaceuticals/Biotech
Plastics/Rubber
Other Manufacturing

Industry Focus
Design & Development
Electrical & Electronics
Energy
Environmental
Facilities & Operations
Labor Relations
Manufacturing Technology
Materials
Quality
Safety
Supply Chain

Amazon

About Us
Editorial Contacts
Advertise with Us

Our Partner Sites
Chem.Info
ECN
Food Manufacturing
IMPO (Industrial Maintenance & Plant Operation)
Medical Design Technology
Pharmaceutical Processing
Product Design & Development
R & D Magazine
Wireless Design & Development
Wireless Week



Manufacturers Struggle To Hire Despite Unemployment
Edited by Manufacturing.net Staff
Manufacturing.Net - November 12, 2009

Printer Friendly     E-mail to a Colleague


DEARBORN, Mich. -- As manufacturers eliminate the mainly repetitive, assembly type jobs, they still have unfilled job openings for high-skilled workers, according to a study by Deloitte, The Manufacturing Institute and Oracle.

The study found that almost one-third of companies reported some level of shortages. Companies, particularly those in aerospace and defense and life science sectors, are having difficulty finding skilled production workers, scientists, and engineers.

“This is certainly an employer’s market, but not as much with manufacturers,” says Mark C. Tomlinson, executive director and general manager of the Society of Manufacturing Engineers. “Manufacturers are looking for employees who are the opposite of the stereotypical factory worker doing repetitive, assembly line work. They are in need of 21st century workers with specialized technical training such as machinists, operators and technicians.”

The study also found that manufacturers aren't working to find these types of workers, or are depending on largely ineffective traditional approaches to managing and developing their employees.

Nearly half of the companies surveyed said many of their current workers have inadequate basic employability skills, including attendance, timeliness, and work ethic. Forty-six percent reported problems with problem-solving skills, and 36 percent said insufficient reading, writing, and communication skills were a problem.

For additional information, visit http://www.deloitte.com/us/peoplemanagementpractices


 


Printer Friendly     E-mail to a Colleague



Talkback!
Manufacturing.net is pleased to provide you an opportunity to share your opinions on any of the news stories or articles on our site. We reserve the right to edit/remove comments.
Viewing 20 User Comments
Add a Comment
Manufacturers Struggle to Hire  11/12/2009 4:11:00 PM
This is once again a desire by someone to drive more HIB visas from the government. This is a crock. Pay a good wage get home grown talent with great skills and technical degrees. Manufacturers like the HIB visas because it equals low wages and tax breaks.
Pay attention!  11/12/2009 4:14:00 PM
You can't find skilled production workers, scientists and engineers cause the kids went to school for a job in the stock market. That's where the easy, BIG money was the past 2-3 years or more. Those skilled people who were laid off are in other jobs now and afraid to come back for fear of cuts again. When the C for C money and the other artificial stimulus money wears off, there will be more job cuts and they do not want to be a part of that AGAIN! Think about it. What is the incentive to take that chance again? There are too many out of a job to give one up for another less secure one. Besides, do you think those folks just sat around waiting for their old job to "open up " again? If you did, you are stupid!
You get what you pay for  11/12/2009 4:36:00 PM
What many employers don't seem to get is that people with skills tend to be high maintenance. We expect, and even demand, to be treated with respect and fairness. It's not even really all about money, but they can't treat us like serfs and cannon fodder and expect us to stick around.
Propaganda  11/12/2009 4:51:00 PM
This is more propaganda diseminated by the multi-nationals to rationalize off-shoring. Plain & simple. The way skilled trades people and engineers have been treated in the last decade speaks loud & clear to the problem. Off-shoring & the "sell-outs" who operate on Wall Street define why there is a problem/shortage. Who in their right mind would want to have anything to do with these trades. In short, you are treated like a cheap whore. That is about as succinct and to the point as I can be.
Manufacturing Struggles  11/12/2009 5:05:00 PM
People do not want to work in manufacturing jobs due to these types of jobs usually are the first to be cut and moved off shore. The people that you do hire have no work ethnics and want you to pay them but they do not want to have to earn the money and they do not understand the meaning of good attendance or work ethnics.
Hear hear!  11/12/2009 5:42:00 PM
"You get what you pay for" and "Propaganda" (see above) hit the nail on the head. Respect for the help is dead.
h1-b  11/12/2009 5:54:00 PM
4:11, could you explain the tax breaks given to companies that hire H1B people? Also, H1B holders must be paid prevailing wage, by law. In my experience H1B, green card, and citizens get the same pay. I'm sure there are exceptions however. And I don't know any tax break for hiring an H1B holder over a citizen, but I could be wrong.
YES THIS IS PROPAGANDA  11/12/2009 6:56:00 PM
The previous comments are all correct, this is just more propaganda. What happened to the days when employers RETRAINED their employees to take on the new jobs?????
People go where the money is....  11/12/2009 9:56:00 PM
Excessive greed in America is the reason for the lack of skilled workers. Skilled workers had their salaries clawed back by greedy executives who felt it necessary to get multi-million dollar bonuses at the expense of the workers. Now those workers who got shafted have moved to other industries to get their piece of the pie. Why take a chance that some worthless C level executive will sacrifice the worker's salary to make a gain in their own salary. Executives need to stop taking so much and plough some of that money back into their "most valuable assets" (i.e. supposedly, the employees).
You get what you pay for ?????  11/12/2009 10:00:00 PM
Are you serious?? I think it is about time that people get paid what they are worth, not what they think they are worth. If you want to be treated "special", work for yourself; if you are employed by someone else you are a surf. A skilled technician today is the assembly person of old, toward the bottom of the food chain
Employee survey  11/13/2009 7:36:00 AM
Our research has found that upper management now gets 200 to 300 times as much pay as the highly skilled technical workers. They are highly educated in Business, buyouts, and making wall street happy. However this is offset by very poor people skills, almost no hands on experience, and a short sighted outlook driven by a regessive bonus structure. The survey continues stating that if these conditions continue the next thing to go offshore will be the present management as many developing countries have skilled, experienced managers who will work for 30% of the present poorly trained and over paid group. It will be far less costly, the survey continues, to bring seveal managers into this country rather then move a whole company out of it. Stock holders were delighted with the prosects of increased profits for almost no investment.
How Much?  11/13/2009 8:03:00 AM
What percentge of complaintant company's work force has these problems? What is the average wage of these companies? Of the reading and communication skills problems, is this related to immigrant status? Are drugs involved?Are the cited problems high school graduates?
Ten of the above missed the message in the article  11/13/2009 1:25:00 PM
When companies in general speak of a shortage of skilled workers, they are not speaking of your average assemblers, but of educated people with specific knowledge and a skills package suitable for the situation at hand. Pay for the right persons is good, job security is more a function of loyalty and good work habits than it is of contractural issues. The auto industry can't really be compared to any "real world" manufacturing, as years of Union demands, weak management and largess in compensation have skewed their pay scale beyond reason. There, we have people doing a job that does not actually require much knowledge or skill, being paid (including all fringes)the equivalent of $149,000 per year, when graduate engineers elsewhere often start at less than $60,000, which is less than the base pay (less fringes)of an auto plant laborer. This, I believe is why many very intellegent people opt to disregard their credentials and instead take a job for which they are overqualified. I'm a controls engineer, and have worked in the profession for over 40 years, yet am paid (including fringes)far less than the unskilled jobs at auto plants. Is this right or reasonable? No. Can it be fixed? Possibly. But there will be great pain for those who have built their lifestyles on an income far greater than they could command elsewhere. AND, we as a country MUST quit exporting manufacturing jobs!!
skills testing  11/14/2009 9:41:00 AM
Employers are not using scientific testing to sort out the people who really ahve aptitude and skills from thosw who do not. The people are there.
Expert Labor  11/15/2009 10:32:00 AM
The short term job offers for skilled positions would be filled if they weren't short term. I have a degree but I'm not willing to quit a job I already have and move for a job that may not be there next year. The way to get skilled workers is to offer them stability and a chance to grow into the job like I have done. Then the worker will be a perfect match for the job going forward.
WHAT?!?!  11/17/2009 4:34:00 PM
11/12/2009 10:00:00 PM, You sir, are an @$$! You sound like my boss whio is an @$$ also. And I AM working on my own gig and have been for 5 years cause I'm tired of making "the man" rich (they wear $15K WATCHES TO THE MEETING BUT GIVE US PAY CUTS!) and being treated like crap.
One good point!  11/17/2009 8:14:00 PM
After reading this article and reviewing the comments from some of the readers, it appears as though the manufacturer's do have one valid point: insufficient reading, WRITING, and communication skills do appear to be a problem. I do agree with others however who think that the manufacturers want to hire people with HIB visas because it's cheaper for them than hiring the talent we have right here.
Under trained, over paid  11/18/2009 12:59:00 PM
I can attest to the shortage of skilled(or willing. We are in the service industry servicing industrial equipment. We have been trying to fill a technician spot for the last 10 months. the pay is in the mid 20's to start with experience, great health benefits at no cost to employee and an incredible monthly bonus program based on the techs invoicables for the month. We have been dluged with union employees from the airports who service the baggage trucks etc. They can barely construct a sentence that is understandable, they want to start at $40/hr. they expect 3 weeks vacation to start and seem upset that we expect them to provide their own hand tools like wrenches. They have all been brainwashed by the unions that they are actually worth that much. you ask them to calculate a load percentage and they have no grasp of math or even problem solving. We provide technical profiency tests for mechanical aptitude and I am actually frightened by some of the results considering what these individuals claimed they were responsible for. It's no wonder planes aren't falling from the sky. We can't fill the spot until we find someone who is not only technically competent but able to communicate intelligently to our customers. I am truly dismayed by the choice of candidates. When we did hire an ex-union employee, they where fine for 2 - 3 weeks and then started to complain about every aspect of the job including the fact that we didn't have election day off to go vote. Did anybody else know that? alot of unions get election day off paid!!, obviously has something to do with a few political connections. I mean really, how long does it take to vote? and aren't the polls open to 7 or 8pm? We are in deep s**t with all these unions brainwashing the average person into believing they are due great incomes without personal investment.
"Hear hear!" Redux  11/20/2009 12:36:00 PM
Some of us are in the inenviable position of seeing that there is an overabundance of available engineering talent. An employer in need of a specialized skill set would much rather steal talent from a competitor than develop talent internally. My assumption is that the employers who are whining about a shortage of talent are the same ones who adamantly refuse to develop talent internally. This is myopic; it's disrespectful to the help, and bad for society and the country.
The Real Reason !!!  11/27/2009 3:18:00 AM
The companies talk all this crap about unskilled workers. The truth is they have out-engineered the ability of todays worker to catch up. Even with 2 to 4 year degrees you still would not be able to be proficient with this high tech that we have today. Most of this technology has evolved over the past 60 years and has been refined by engineers from prestigious schools over the same span, day in day out. Lack of skilled workers is just a scapegoat excuse for the shortsightedness of the industry to who is going to keep this stuff produced. Todays "unskilled worker" would most likely have been an uber tech back in the 40's 50's, but the bar has been so highly set that most are unable to cross it! I also agree greatly with "propaganda" and "People go where the money is...." above. America is suffering from a crisis of GREED and sellouts of the american worker. This also describes why there is such a large gap between rich and poor and why the middle-class is dissapearing.


Add a Comment...

E-Mail:
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Subject:
Comment:

 

     



   





Flatbed trucking, flatbed shipping, flatbed carriers



Pharmaceuticals/Biotech

Bristol-Myers Squibb Freezing Salaries

Former Bristol-Myers Worker Charged With Trade Theft

GlaxoSmithKline Profit Rises 66 Percent


Chemicals/Petroleum

Oregon Groups Seek To Ban BPA From Baby Products

Maryland May Ban BPA Products

Emerging Markets Boost Dow Chemical Profit

Medical

Becton Dickinson Expands Product Recall

Nipro Buys Home Diagnostics For $215M

Boston Scientific Settles J&J Lawsuit For $1.73B
News Video